In a world where speed and efficiency are the order of the day, electric kettles have found a well-deserved place as the go-to appliance that facilitates the preparation of your favorite hot drink. Of course, there is still a segment of the population that remains nostalgic for the golden days, the classic taste, or even the hissing of steaming water, and this is where the confrontation that is the subject of today’s article emerged: stovetop kettle Vs. electric kettle: which one is better?
Most of us feel better starting our day with coffee, tea or any other hot beverage. Various studies have even shown their beneficial nature. They help us with a sharper focus, better digestion, and even a feeling of satiety that can keep us focus on our work schedule. Kettles have made a huge contribution here: helping us heat water quickly and effortlessly. But when it comes to the purchase of such an electrical appliance, due to the abundance of variables on the market, we may feel overwhelmed.
Should we opt for the good, reliable, old fashioned stovetop kettle which reminds us of homey environments, smelling of our favorite cookies or opt for the modern, efficient electric kettle? Continue reading this post to learn the pros and cons for either option!
Pros and Cons of Stove Top Kettles – Is the Traditional Method Still the Best?
What definitely works in favor of stove top kettles is their ability to function outside of modern utilities.
Electric kettles depend on electricity and have to be plugged in for functioning. They cannot work in power cuts, or support your outdoor activities like camping or picnics. Whereas a stove top kettle can work on any stove and you can even put it on a campfire.
Stove kettle facilitates a traditional way of making tea or coffee. It is capable of heating water above boiling point. Some people like to brew their tea in boiling water for extracting the true flavor of tea leaves. Stove kettles are easy to clean and work on induction, gas, electric stove and even over a campfire.
The Pros of Stove Top Kettles
Stove kettles come at a more affordable price. Those with a tight budget need not spend extra bucks on electric kettles when stove kettles work just fine.
Although electric kettles are also coming in very elegant designs and colors, stovetop kettles have more variety in when it comes to looks and matching any designer fantasy. You can easily choose one that blends in your kitchen’s interior or stands out, depending on preference. They also come in various shapes and materials, though kitchen grade stainless steel and glass are the healthiest options.
Ideal for Coffee
People prefer stove top kettles since they can make coffee directly in them and are easier to clean than the electric kettle. Keep in mind that in order to savor the best coffee it it recommended to let that boiling water chill out (literally) for about 30 seconds before adding the coffee grounds.
The ideal water temperature for brewing coffee is around 202-206 degrees Fahrenheit. We don’t all have a temperature-controlled electric kettle at home, but water boils at around 212 degrees Fahrenheit, so we rely on the kettle’s whistle.
Because boiling water is a little too hot, pouring it directly on the coffee grounds can cause them to extract too much too soon, leaving a bitter taste in your cup. Violent bubbling water also unnecessarily agitates the grounds, which can result in uneven extraction.
Best stovetop Kettle
Among the variety of stove top kettles available out there there are 2 models that we consider worth mentioning: the iconic Hario V60 “Buono” drip, gooseneck, coffee kettle and the best seller, classic, Primula Stewart whistling stovetop tea kettle.
Hario V60 “Buono” Drip Kettle Stovetop Gooseneck Coffee Kettle 1.2L, Stainless Steel, Silver
Boil water quickly for manual coffee brewing, tea, or cooking. Perfect for everyday kitchen use and small enough to be a countertop necessity. Buono, which is both minimalist and stylish, complements any kitchen design.
Japanese Design: Stainless steel kettle with an ergonomic design for easy, safe pouring; ideal for for manual coffee brewing, tea or cooking;
Minimalist and stylish, Buono perfectly complements any kitchen design;
It does NOT react to the boiling water (so the drink you are preparing will not have any off-taste that comes from the brewing tools)
Small capacity: usually this product is used for preparing limited servings; especially brewed coffee or tea.
Impractical to brew directly in: due to its design you need to prepare your drinks in a separate, preferably, borosilicate or ceramic, pitcher/cup/jar, because of how borosilicate is non-reactive regardless of temp or pH
Does not have a whistle or indicator when it’s boiling
Primula Stewart Whistling Stovetop Tea Kettle Food Grade Stainless Steel, 1.5-Quart, Brushed with Black Handle
The Stewart tea kettle is made of durable, food grade stainless steel that will last. This kettle will boil water in no time and features a flip-up whistling spout.
Lightweight and easy to handle it ensure no spill pouring!
Good quality of stainless steel sturdy and easy to clean
Fast water heating: The teapot has a wide enough bottom diameter for any kind of stove burners and the egg-kind shape provides fast reach of boiling temperature;
Emits a pleasant whistle to alert you that your water is boiling;
Budget Friendly: it truly provides great value for its price
Tricky to clean: You’ll need a bottle brush to clean it as the opening is a bit small;
Flexible “easy storage” handle: can affect maneuverability and requires careful handling when pouring hot water. Also it can get pretty hot so you may need to use a potholder if you take it right of the stove;
Whistles very loud when the water begins to boil;
Finicky plastic components: if not handled with care they get ruined.
Everything You Need to Know About Electric Kettles
Electric kettles are almost indispensable in most kitchen these days, thanks to their convenience and versatility. Equipped with a heating resistance, generally submerged, they heat water fast and safely, using thermal transfer. With the help of electric kettles, you can easily heat up water for tea, coffee, hot chocolate or even soups.
Some models boast features like temperature control, ideal for tea preparation, auto-shut off, for extra safety and some keep water at a certain temperature, making it convenient to prepare your hot drink at any time.
The Benefits of Using an Electric Kettle
Electric kettles heat water faster than stove kettles. These high voltage kettles take no more than few seconds to heat water and bring it to a boiling point. As compared to the electric kettles, stovetop kettles take longer to boil water.
Unlike stovetop kettles, electric kettles do not depend on the stove to work. The best part of having an electric kettle is that you can place it where you want, in the office, in the RV, in your student dorm, in the living room. All you have to do is plug it in and enjoy your hot drink in no time.
Technology has reached electric kettles too, making them smarter than the traditional stovetop kettle. Mere boiling water is not enough. Some teas are too sensitive to be boiled, and their real flavor and taste may be destroyed with over boiling. In the same way, some drinks like coffee, need water above boiling point. What some electric kettle models do these days is to give an accurate temperature control. You can heat water at your required temperature and extract the real flavor of green tea, coffee, white tea or any other drink.
Energy Efficient: Which Is More Energy Efficient Electric Kettle Or Stove Top?
An electric kettles performs better than a stovetop kettle when it comes to heating water. The electric kettle is more energy efficient than the stovetop kettle. The heating element below the kettle directly heats the water, and no electricity is lost. On the stove, the flames surround the kettles heat the air around as well as the water inside. More energy is wasted this way, and thus electric kettles save more energy.
Indeed, the kettle is particularly effective because it is specifically designed to heat water: its resistors are very close to the water tank, and therefore it heats it up very quickly. According to tests conducted by Tree Hugger magazine, the energy efficiency of a kettle exceeds 80%, while that of a microwave only approaches 67% and that of a gas hob 30%.
While the time it takes for the water to boil has no impact on cost, it can be important in terms of time savings. Stiftung Warentest gives the following values for the energy requirement and the duration of 1 liter of water:
- Kettle : 0.115 kWh, duration: approx. 3:18 minutes
- Induction hob without boost function : 0.123 kWh, duration: approx. 4:36 minutes
- Gas stove : 0.27 kWh, duration: 5:18 minutes
- Glass ceramic hob : 0.169 kWh, duration: 5:42 minutes
- Stovetop : 0.208 kWh, Duration: 6:18 minutes
- Microwave : 0.231 kWh, Duration: 12:18 minutes
Based on the average gas and electricity these days average prices can be calculated for orientation. It remains to be seen how the values will change in the future:
Boil water: average cost
If you take the values from April 2022, the following prices result:
|Appliance||Boil 1 liter of water||Annual cost of 1 liter of water per day|
|Induction hob without boost function||4.6 cents||€16.67|
|Gas stove||3.7 cents||€13.57|
|Glass ceramic hob||6.3 cents||€22.91|
Of course, different nuances appear here too, considering that most of the time we heat more water in an electric kettle than it is necessary for a cup of tea, and then we still make a certain amount of waste. Also it is worth considering the gas price evolution since at the moment it is the cheapest resource.
Is Electric Kettle Faster Than Stove top Kettle?
If you want to be time efficient while boiling water, the obvious choice is the electric kettle: Seth Stevenson, writing for Slate, says an electric kettle will get the job done in about half the time.
Electric kettles come with an auto shutoff system. An electric kettle immediately shuts off when water reaches the required temperature. This feature prevents overheating but also saves energy. Stovetop kettles have whistling options, and a loud sound can alert when water is ready, but still, they cannot automatically shut off which can lead to serious domestic accidents.
Best Electric Kettle
Just like in the case of stovetop kettles, there are many attractive electric kettle models which come in a variety of shapes, sizes, various functions, but we selected two models that seem to be the most popular: the budget friendly, popular Ovente Electric Hot Water Kettle 1.7 Liter, 1100 Watt and the highly recommended COSORI Glass Electric Kettle with Stainless Steel Filter and Inner Lid, 1500W.
Ovente Electric Hot Water Kettle 1.7 Liter with LED Light, 1100 Watt BPA-Free with Auto Shut-Off
This Ovente electric kettle delivers a convenient and hassle-free experience. The handle never gets hot so you can handle it without any worries. A wide opening boiling chamber and a removable filter make cleaning a breeze. The 30-inch cord wraps neatly to its base for easy storage.
Auto shut-off and boil dry protection features provide added peace of mind and make sure the kettle turns off when it should ;
Easy to manage, you can take the kettle off it’s electric plate once the water is hot enough and carry it where you need it;
Great Value for Price: it does the job fast and secure
The power cord: is very thick and very stiff and it my bother you until you put the appliance in the desired position
Made of BPA free plastic it can give a chemical odor at first that eventually washes off after bringing to boil multiple times with a few drops of detergent.
COSORI Electric Glass Kettle with Stainless Steel Filter, 1500W 1.7L, LED Indicator Auto Shut-Off
The Cosori electric kettle is quite the looker with it’s with superior-quality 304 stainless steel and borosilicate glass that keep the water pure and taste free. 7 US cups / 1.7 L large capacity with accurate cup & liters lines, you can brew more in less time for the whole family.
Aesthetically pleasing: complete glass kettle with a glass pouring spout and built-in metal strainer, ideal for those that do not want their water in contact with controversial materials;
Very visible LED ring light that tells you when element is on and goes off when finished.
The clear water reservoir with markings on both sides let’s you easily asses it’s status
It is not the easiest to clean since the glass part might require extra careful handling.
Handle is hard, not comfortable to grip especially when pouring at maximum capacity (7 cups) but that is easily adjustable
The top lid doesn’t pop up all the way, making filling access more difficult
We have discussed both types of kettles in detail, and now it is the time of the final verdict. No doubt, electric kettles take the lead in being more convenient, portable, energy efficient and speedy. However, it all boils down to one factor that is personal preferences. What you choose for you is a matter of your personal convenience and preferences.
|Hario V60 "Buono" Drip Kettle Stovetop Gooseneck Coffee Kettle...||$66.67 $39.99||Buy on Amazon|
|Primula Stewart Whistling Stovetop Tea Kettle Food Grade...||$12.99 $8.99||Buy on Amazon|
|OVENTE Electric Kettle, Hot Water, Heater 1.7 Liter - BPA Free...||43,070 Reviews||$26.99 $15.99||Buy on Amazon|
|COSORI Electric Kettle, Tea Kettle Pot, 1.7L/1500W, Stainless...||34,645 Reviews||$27.99||Buy on Amazon|